Monday, May 16, 2011

Unlikely things

I like speculation about the future. I even like optimistic technological fantasies, but I think that they can be destructive when people don't realize that they are fantasies. Things that I won't hold my breath for, though some might happen in the far future.

1. Easy life extension

2. Mind uploading

3. Cheap, plentiful alternative energy for automobiles

4. Extensive human presence in space

5. The cure for cancer, as opposed to better treatments for some cancers

6. FTL of any sort, including sorts that don't contradict general relativity.

Monday, May 9, 2011

Could Narnia be bad for kids?

Narnia is a lovely fantasy world and the tales told of Narnia are often tales of moral redemption.
How could it be bad? The problem I see is that the Narnia tales present escaping into another world as natural and healthy. While this is true to an extent, ultimately one finds or fails to solutions to one's troubles in the real world. Shouldn't kids be taught that.

Saturday, May 7, 2011

Speculations -- No Jesus

If the Christian religion had never existed, what would be the cultural consequences. Here are my guesses.

1. Europe and America would still be religious but a mix of faiths might have survived the fall of Rome. Manichean and Mithrasist temples might dot the land. Paganism might not have died out but it would still have had to evolve, becoming less magical and more mystical. On the other hand, if Europe wasn't united under one religion, Islam might have conquered Western Europe.

2. There might be less interest in equality. Christianity, early on, stressed equality between ethnic groups. "No Jew or Greek, no slave or free." While the New Testament is silent on slavery and suggests that women should be subject to their husbands in spiritual matters, Christianity is still firm on the idea your capacity for salvation doesn't depend on things like martial prowess or social status. From these ideas of metaphysical equality, ideas of equality in this world could readily spring.

3. The conquest of the new world might have been somewhat less aggressive if Europeans did not have the fig leaf of one true religion to hide their greed behind.

4. There might be less science and technology. Monotheism leads readily to the idea of universal natural laws. If natural forces were seen as operating according to there own whims rather than ordered by one God, our understanding of them might not have advanced as much as it has. Some things, such as probability theory could advance through analysis alone, but the idea of finding out natures regularities through observation and experiment might not have gotten off the ground as quickly.

5. Sexual morality would be affected but it's impossible to say how. Christianity, despite it's demand for monogamy and hetrosexuality, is hardly the only tradition that restricts sexual behavior.

Thursday, May 5, 2011

Husband's Worries

My husband worries that paying our oldest daughter to read classics, as he has, will harm her intrinsic motivation to read. I think this is true but I am glad she did read those books. Because of that she is aware of aspects of human experience most nine year olds would not be. I don't think she can fully appreciate them, but I think parents never see the depths of their children, especially the darker depths which children keep hidden out of prudence.

Something Blindingly Obvious

Single payer health care would make US middle-aged workers more employable by removing a major cost of employing such people.

Monday, May 2, 2011

Old Man's War

I really liked John Scalzi's Old Man's War. As a piece of genre fiction it had many enjoyable features. The soldier's in the book were, for the most part, intelligent, likable, people who tried to survive as best they could in a horrible situation. Unlike Heinlein, Scalzi doesn't write all-wise father figures or attempt to teach political lessons to the reader.

Scalzi also didn't spend a lot of ink showing off his technical knowledge to the reader. I probably like technical speculation more than the average SF reader does, but it can get in the way of telling a good story. I did think the green soldiers were a bit silly, but I don't know if would bother most people.

I could have wished for more interesting aliens. The bit about eating humans got old after a while, but the mysterious Consu were genuinely frightening.

All in all, Old Man's War, isn't mind blowing but entertains without visibly showing off or insulting the reader's intelligence.

Wednesday, April 27, 2011

More on Fighting -- Writing Training

While most fiction doesn't take place in a dojo, in my short time practicing martial arts I've seen some interesting interpersonal conflicts that could be used in stories.

1. Masters get old and sometimes fat -- How do you show you are as good as you used to be or come to terms with the fact you are not?

2. People have issues -- How do you deal with people who fight out of control, not staying in the bounds needed to keep training safe? In general, how do you work with people who have trouble with discipline?

3. People have more issues -- How do you deal students, who because of there physical or mental limits, have more difficulty than others?

4. People have varying experience and some people who have experience in other settings or with other martial arts will resent being classed as beginners.